Why is normalization context not set for POST and collection routes?

[tezvi]

Hi!

This issue is related to b1590b8
commited by @teohhanhui, help would be appreciated dude.

This line https://github.com/api-platform/core/blame/master/src/EventListener/ReadListener.php#L66 is preventing building of full request attributes normalization context parameters.

I'm depending on $request->attributes->set('_api_normalization_context', $normalizationContext); which is set further bellow.
What is the reason to skip setup of normalization context when POST and collection_operation_name is set?

I'm using custom controllers here and there for handling POST requests and using deserializer group from request attributes when injecting DTO objects in controller action method (using Request ParamConverter).

Thanks for your input!

[tezvi]

Well I'm a bit in a hurry so I managed to fix it on my behalf, though I'm borrowing ApiPlatform internal stuff :\

private function createApiPlatformNormalizationContext(Request $request): array
{
    $attributes = RequestAttributesExtractor::extractAttributes($request);

    return $this->contextBuilder->createFromRequest($request, true, $attributes);
}

[teohhanhui]

Sorry, I don't understand the issue. The ReadListener should do nothing if it's a POST operation, as there's nothing to be read when you're creating a new resource.

[tezvi]

Hi teohhanhui!
I'm using a custom controller for POST operation and I need to know API operation context (ie. serialization / deserialization group) in order to deal with specifics like deserializing and validating non api-platform input etc.
I used to rely on api-platform request attributes which were originally set in ReadListener. Now they are not initialized for POST operations and my code does not work anymore.

So my point is that API operation normalization context attributes should be available in request attributes collection regardless of operation HTTP method, at least to identify that current request is handled by api-platform with specific serialization / deserialization rules.

[teohhanhui]

_api_normalization_context attribute is for our internal use only, for built-in data providers (as indicated by the comments).

You should use the RequestAttributesExtractor, so that's correct. We should perhaps unmark it as @internal. @dunglas?

[tezvi]

Yup I'm using RequestAttributesExtractor and it would be nice to remove @internal.
Cheers

[stale]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.