Skip to content

XAML/UWP: incomplete (Win32-only) tree returned silently while app is still loading #27

Description

@asklar

Summary

When targeting a UWP/XAML (and likely WinUI3) app that is still initializing, lvt silently returns a Win32-only tree (no XAML content), with no warning and exit code 0. An AI agent targeting a just-launched app therefore gets an incomplete tree and cannot tell it's incomplete.

Repro (Calculator, cold start)

Kill Calculator, relaunch, and dump repeatedly right after the window appears:
\
dump1-5: 4 elements calcXaml=False (~100ms each) <- Windows.UI.Xaml not loaded yet
dump6-8: 617 elements calcXaml=True (~7700ms each) <- full stitched tree
\
The ApplicationFrameHost window appears within ~250ms, but the hosted app process hasn't loaded its XAML tree yet, so framework detection finds no XAML and lvt returns the Win32 skeleton only.

Impact

  • Partial output with no error signal; bad for agents and for cross-invocation element identity (the tree content itself is nondeterministic during startup).

Proposed

  • When XAML/WinUI is expected (host has the runtime) but the collected tree is empty/degenerate, retry with a short backoff.
  • Add an opt-in --wait /--retry\ and/or emit a clear stderr warning when the tree looks incomplete.
  • Found during PR Durable element identity (stable keys) + --query #26 validation.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions